Marco Island - Dina Johnson
1/44
Listing Courtesy Of: Premiere Plus Realty Company
Local Realty Services Provided By: Keller Williams Elite Realty
Overview
What It'll Cost
Neighborhood
Similar Homes

$2,375,000
5134 Kensington High ST, NAPLES, FL 34105
3 Beds
4 Baths
3,450 sq ft
.23 ac
$2,375,000

5134 Kensington High ST, NAPLES, FL 34105

Estimation provided by Keller Williams Realty Inc.
3 Beds
4 Baths
3,450 sq ft
.23 ac
Pending With Contingencies
For Sale
Virtual Tour

Property Description

Welcome to the Kensington Country Club Community! This 3 bed+den/3(1) baths custom Arthur Rutenburg home is a masterpiece of timeless elegance, thoughtfully crafted to offer a seamless blend of comfort and versatility for every lifestyle. From the moment you step into the stunning two-story foyer, the home's grandeur unfolds, with a regal curved staircase and gleaming wood floors setting the tone for a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Spread across two levels, this home offers an abundance of spaces to suit every occasion. The comfortable living room with a gas fireplace, inviting dining room, and versatile bar/entertainment room flow effortlessly into the serene sunroom, the perfect morning retreat. A study with extensive built-ins provides a quiet workspace, while the lanai, complete with a sparkling pool, beckons for outdoor enjoyment. The pool heater, variable speed pump, and Jandy Wi-Fi control system (2024) ensure your enjoyment year-round. The heart of the home is the classical kitchen, outfitted with Custom wood cabinets, high-end appliances, including a GE Profile refrigerator (2024), a Thermador wall oven with a warming tray, and a sprawling island with a built-in dining table ideal for meal prep, casual dining, or entertaining. Upstairs offers a gracious loft that leads to two spacious guest suites, one being ensuite, offering both comfort and privacy for visitors. There is also a family room that could easily be a 4th sleeping space with close access to a full bathroom. The luxurious, spa-inspired primary ensuite bath features an elegant double vanity, built-in- tub, and walk-in shower, while one oversized walk-in closet has a double-door entry that enhances the suite's appeal. Additional highlights include plantation shutters throughout, 2 car garage plus golf cart garage, a Mitsubishi mini-split garage air conditioner (2021), and a Culligan whole-house water system with reverse osmosis filtration (2023). A newer roof (2019) and a completed gutter system add value and peace of mind to the house. This residence offers an unparalleled fusion of refined elegance, ultimate comfort, and situated on the 9th hole of the pristine golf course—creating an extraordinary living experience that effortlessly combines luxury with everyday convenience. A delicious bonus is enjoying Bananas and Myers lemons picked fresh from your own trees!

Property Details

Compare This Home
Overview
Property Type
Single Family Residence
Property Size
3,450 sq ft
Year Built
1995
Days on Site
72 Days
HVAC
Central Electric, Fireplace(s), Ceiling Fan(s)
Parking
3 Parking Spaces
HOA Fees
$599/Q
Dina Johnson REALTOR®
Marco Island
SL3451288

Activity History

VIEWS
0
SAVES
0
SHARES
0
Data provided by Keller Williams Realty, Inc.
Upcoming Open Houses
No open houses are currently scheduled for this property. Don't worry - you can always schedule a tour, or get additional help from your agent.

Estimated Monthly Payment

Purchase Price: $2,375,000
Principal + Interest
$0 (0%)
Property Tax
$0 (0%)
Home Insurance
$0 (0%)
HOA/Condo Fee
$0 (0%)
Mortgage Insurance
$0 (0%)
Purchase Price
$
Purchase price has been changed to something other than the currently listed price.
Down Payment
%
$
Interest Rate
%
Loan Type
Property Tax
%
$
Home Insurance /year
$
HOA/Condo Fees /month
$
Mortgage Insurance /month
$
Credit Score
This calculator is just an estimate. Contact Keller Williams for full and accurate assessment.

Price & Tax History

Date
Event
Price
01/10/2025
Listed
$2,375,000
(+181.07%)
06/11/2014
Sold
$845,000
(-22.48%)
12/15/2005
Sold
$1,090,000
(+107.62%)
11/15/1999
Sold
$525,000
(+337.5%)
07/29/1994
Sold
$120,000
Year
Property Tax
Assessed Value
Assessed Value is a combination of the land and additions.
2023
$7,700
(-3.99%)
$798,437
No Breakdown Available
2021
$8,020
(+4.14%)
$752,604
No Breakdown Available
2019
$7,701
(-4.15%)
$725,526
Land 218,152 + Additions 507,374
2017
$8,034
$752,417
No Breakdown Available
The Property History data displayed is obtained from public records and/or MLS feeds from the local jurisdiction in which the applicable property is located. As kw.com cannot guarantee that all public records and MLS data is accurate and error-free, it is important that you contact your agent directly in order to obtain the most up-to-date information available.

Explore Kensington Park

Go to Neighborhood

market snapshot

Currently no active listings available that meet the criteria for market statistics calculations.

Nearby Schools

No data to show right now.

No data to show right now.

Disclaimer: This information is provided by Precisely and subject to change. Please check the applicable school district.

Transit & Commute

Estimated commute times from Kensington Park
Car-Dependent Walkable Very Walkable
Dina Johnson REALTOR®
Marco Island
SL3451288

Similar Properties

Properties with similar features, attributes, and price to this current listing
Featured Properties
Sold
New - 1,748 Hours
Open House
$2,375,000
3 bd
4 ba
3,450 sq ft
0.23 ac
5134 Kensington High ST, NAPLES, FL 34105
Listing Courtesy Of: Premiere Plus Realty Company

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. For more info, read our Cookie Policy. By clicking “Accept” or continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.